iMac G5, refurbished, needs repair, runaround
Sunday, December 18th, 2005Buying an Apple refurbished computer from the online Apple Store? Be ready for a few problems.
I purchased a refurbished Apple iMac G5 (20-inches, 2.0 GHz) last month, and had to take it in for service, since 2 of the 3 screws that held the chassis together were damaged. One screw was broken inside, so that it would turn freely but never catch (or release). The other screw was tightened so hard that I couldn’t turn it. I ended up partially stripping it.
My goal was simply to upgrade the memory. 512Mb seems like a lot, but even a powerful iMac needs more memory, so I bought two 1Gb modules and went to install them, and then discovered that I couldn’t open my iMac.
I called AppleCare, and they told me to take it to the local Apple Store, which I did. But the Genius at the store took a look, and said that it was “DOA” and should be exchanged through the Apple online/phone sales department. He also suggested that Apple cross-ship me a new iMac while I returned the old one to them.
After 45 minutes on the phone with AppleCare, I was told that no, that repair needs to be done in the store, and no, they wouldn’t cross-ship me a new iMac because it wasn’t standard procedure. Fortunately we were still at the mall, so I dragged the iMac back to the Apple Store and explained everything to the Genius.
After much hemming, hawing, and reluctance, he finally agreed to fix the problem. I left the iMac there while they ordered the replacement parts and completed the repairs. The next day, another Genius called me and told me that the repair would not be covered under my warranty (despite the fact that I purchased the AppleCare extended plan) since it was “abuse”. So I explained the whole story to him again - it came that way in the box, and it needs to be fixed. He finally agreed to repair the iMac at no charge.
A few days later, I got a call from the Apple Store and was told that the iMac was ready to be picked up. I did so, took it home, and upgraded the memory with no problems.
I’m not sure if everyone gets the runaround like this, but I’d feel better about this if somebody at Apple would step up and own this problem and drive it to completion, rather than pointing fingers and saying that some other person/department needs to fix this. It should not take a lot of effort and persistance to convince Apple to fix the product which was shipped to me in a faulty condition.
I’m using the iMac now, and with its 2Gb memory upgrade (and a fast, really fast Western Digital 74Gb Raptor SATA hard drive) it’s the fastest computer that I’ve ever used. Airport wireless connectivity isn’t the greatest, but I’m on an Ethernet connection now, and it just flies.